Racial equity cannot wait: a call for collective action in Edinburgh and Scotland

Read the PDF of this document here

Aala Ross, Co-Head of the Regenerative Futures Fund in Edinburgh, reflects on the challenges of advocating for racial equity in Scotland, the importance of supporting community-led organisations, and the collective responsibility of public funders and the third sector to build a more just society.


Edinburgh and Scotland have made important commitments to tackling poverty and building fairer, more inclusive communities, but public funders and the third sector still have quite the distance to go in recognising how racism contributes to and intersects with the inequalities people experience, and in acting on this to ensure that the communities most affected by poverty and racism are given the trust, resources and influence to shape the solutions.

For the Regenerative Futures Fund, supporting racial equity is an important part of tackling poverty, rather than a separate or competing priority. Experiences of poverty are shaped by a range of factors, including race, class, gender, disability and migration status, and these can compound one another in ways that are not always recognised by mainstream services or funding programmes. If we want to make meaningful progress towards ending poverty, we need to be willing to acknowledge these differences and support the people and organisations who are best placed to address them.

And yet we know that progressing racial equity requires more than the work of individual funds or community organisations, or statements of solidarity that are not matched by action. Public funders and the third sector must use their collective influence and resources to challenge existing inequalities, redistribute power and stand alongside communities whose rights and dignity are increasingly being contested.

Part of this requires us to look more critically at whose voices are represented in public conversations, whose experiences inform decisions, and whose knowledge and leadership are valued. And while representation is welcome, it is equally important that we examine how we understand poverty, how we distribute resources and power, and whose organisations we recognise as deserving of investment. At a time of increasing political polarisation and hostility towards racialised communities, there is an urgent need for public funders and the third sector to come together to create the conditions for equitable funding, and for Black and People of Colour (BPOC) communities to be visible, heard and able to shape the future of their communities on their own terms. 


What do we mean by equity and justice?

There are important differences between equality, equity, fairness and justice, and these distinctions influence how public and charitable resources are distributed. Equality means giving everyone the same resources and opportunities, regardless of their circumstances. Equity recognises that people face different barriers and have different needs, and that resources and support must reflect these differences if everyone is to have a genuine opportunity to thrive. Equity goes beyond equality by addressing the inequalities that equal treatment alone cannot overcome. 

Similarly, fairness is concerned with whether people are treated reasonably and resources are distributed fairly. Justice goes further, asking why inequalities exist, how existing systems, powers and structures perpetuate them, and what needs to change. A just approach seeks to fairly distribute resources and goes further to address the underlying power imbalances that determine who has access to resources, opportunities and influence in the first place. 

The language we use to describe fairness, equality, equity and justice is not simply a matter of terminology; it shapes the judgements we make about inequality and how resources should be distributed. When these terms are used interchangeably, or without examining what they mean in practice, assumptions about what is fair or reasonable can go unchallenged, even when they reinforce existing inequalities. 

Racism shapes who has access to economic opportunities, institutional support and decision-making, but also whose knowledge, experience and leadership are recognised and valued. Without understanding how racism operates through institutions and structures, it is easy to overlook the barriers facing BPOC communities and mistake equal treatment for equitable outcomes. It can also lead us to make assumptions about who is best placed to lead work, whose expertise should be trusted and where resources should go. 

A damaging assumption in parts of Edinburgh's third sector is that established organisations, often with little lived experience of the communities concerned, are best placed to lead simply because they have a track record, institutional knowledge and the ability to navigate complex systems. When this assumption prevails, the expertise and leadership of organisations rooted in BPOC communities are undervalued, and resources remain concentrated in institutions that may involve those communities as service users or participants without transferring the power and resources needed to build their own agency. 

 

Supporting communities to lead their own work

One of the challenges facing the third sector is that although there is increasing recognition of the importance of lived experience and community participation, we do not always translate this principle into the way we fund and support organisations. Smaller, community-rooted organisations are often expected to contribute their knowledge, provide access to communities or deliver particular activities, while larger and more established organisations retain the funding, infrastructure and influence. We need to ask why the expertise of communities is so readily welcomed, but their leadership and the organisations they have built are not always given the same recognition or support. Investing in community-led organisations is a way of redistributing power, strengthening collective agency and enabling communities to shape the decisions that affect their lives. 

 

There is also an important distinction between funding work that benefits BPOC communities and investing directly in those communities' own organisations, leadership and capacity. Too often, BPOC communities are recognised as beneficiaries of services or activities delivered by others, without receiving the resources, infrastructure and support needed to develop their own organisations, set their own priorities and build lasting influence.  

 

The concept of 'by-and-for' organisations, explored in research commissioned by Lloyds Bank Foundation and the Legal Education Foundation and undertaken by the New Economics Foundation, offers an important perspective on this. The research highlights the distinctive contribution of organisations that are led by and serve the communities they represent, where lived experience is central to how they understand problems, build relationships and develop responses. It also describes the considerable challenges these organisations face in securing sustainable funding, particularly when funding processes and expectations are designed around larger organisations with greater administrative capacity and established institutional relationships. 

 

At the Regenerative Futures Fund, we are proud that 56% of our funding has been allocated to by-and-for organisations. This is an important achievement, particularly given how rarely funding is deliberately directed towards organisations led by the communities experiencing the inequalities the funding seeks to address. However, this risks remaining an isolated example unless the wider funding landscape changes. We cannot address the long-standing underinvestment in by-and-for organisations through one fund alone, nor should communities have to rely on occasional funding programmes to receive the recognition and resources they deserve. 

 

We need funders and larger third sector organisations to consider not only which communities they are reaching, but where their resources are going, who holds the relationships with those communities, and who has the opportunity to shape the work. This means being prepared to fund organisations for the long term, recognise the value of their existing knowledge and relationships, and support them to develop their own priorities rather than expecting them to fit into structures and programmes designed elsewhere.

 

Our collective responsibility

Making the case for racial equity is not always easy, particularly at a time when far-right movements are becoming increasingly visible and emboldened, and when anti-racist work and the organisations receiving funding to support racialised communities are themselves being targeted. Across Scotland and the wider UK, we have seen increasingly hostile rhetoric towards racialised communities, migrants, refugees, and people seeking asylum, alongside attacks, intimidation and attempts to undermine organisations working to support these communities. There is a growing tendency to portray investment in racial equity as preferential treatment, or to question the legitimacy of funding organisations led by particular communities, rather than recognising the inequalities that make this investment necessary in the first place. This creates a particularly difficult environment for organisations working to advance social justice, and risks making funders and third sector leaders more cautious at precisely the time when clear leadership and solidarity are needed most. 

 

Funders avoiding these difficult conversations around risks won't make the inequalities disappear, and it cannot be left to racialised communities and the organisations representing them to continually make the case for change, particularly when they are also having to navigate increasing hostility and threats to their work. There is an important role for leaders across the third sector to work together, build relationships and find ways to advocate collectively. This does not mean that we will always agree, or that we should avoid difficult conversations, but it does mean recognising that poverty, racism and social exclusion are interconnected challenges, and that we have a shared responsibility to address them. Those of us working in established organisations and institutions have relationships, resources and influence that can be used to support this work, and we should be prepared to use them. 

 

Developing the Regenerative Futures Fund has involved bringing together residents, community organisations, funders and local authority partners to consider how we might work differently towards a more just Edinburgh. This has required time, trust and a willingness to challenge some of our assumptions about who holds expertise and who should make decisions. It has also demonstrated the value of working across organisations and bringing different perspectives together, particularly when the changes we are trying to achieve cannot be delivered by any one organisation acting alone. We need more of this collaborative leadership across the sector, with organisations prepared to stand alongside one another, speak out against racism and defend the right of communities to organise, lead and receive the resources needed to do so.


What can we do differently?

There are practical steps that funders, public bodies and third sector organisations can take to make this commitment meaningful. Some require changes to how resources are allocated, while others involve challenging established ways of working and being more intentional about whose voices and experiences shape our decisions.

Make public services more accessible and responsive. Public bodies should invest in appropriate training, clear protocols and practical support to ensure that services can work effectively with different communities. This includes trauma-informed approaches, properly funded translation and interpretation, and a willingness to meet communities where they are, rather than expecting people to navigate systems that were not designed with their circumstances in mind. As Scotland considers how to reform and improve public services, inclusion and racial equity must be central to that work, rather than treated as additional considerations.

Ring-fence funding for racial equity and by-and-for organisations. Funding programmes might include dedicated resources for organisations led by-and-for racialised communities, rather than relying on these organisations to compete for a small share of general funding pots. This should include longer-term, unrestricted funding that recognises the importance of organisational development, core costs and the relationships that community organisations hold over time. 

 

Build a community of practice for funders. Funders supporting racial equity and justice in Scotland would benefit from a dedicated space to share learning, develop good practice and consider how funding decisions can better support by-and-for organisations. This could provide an opportunity to share challenges, identify gaps in provision and build the case for a more consistent approach across the funding landscape. 

 

Learn from organisations and funders elsewhere. There is considerable experience of supporting diverse communities and community-led organisations in places such as Birmingham, Bristol and London. Creating opportunities for peer exchange, mentoring and 'buddying' between Scottish organisations and those working in these contexts could help us learn from approaches that have been developed over many years, while recognising that solutions need to reflect Scotland's own communities and circumstances. 

 

Adopt meaningful standards and improve our understanding of need. Frameworks such as the DEI Data Standard can help funders understand who organisations are led by and who benefits from their work. But data collection needs to be accompanied by a broader understanding of the challenges facing by-and-for organisations, including the barriers they encounter in accessing funding, their organisational needs and the particular value they bring to their communities. 

 

Pay attention to who is in the room. Not every change requires a new funding programme or institutional strategy. When organising conferences, consultations, learning events or sector-wide discussions, we should take the time to look around and ask whose voices are missing. Are the organisations closest to the issues represented? Have they been supported to participate, including through payment for their time, accessible venues, translation and childcare where needed? And are they being invited to shape the conversation, rather than simply contribute to it? 

These are not exhaustive solutions, but some paths for public funders and the third sector to work together towards an equitable distribution of resources, influence and opportunity, and to make meaningful progress towards a Scotland where racial equity is advanced as part of a wider pursuit of social justice for all.

They offer a starting point for a different kind of collective action: one that moves beyond good intentions and asks  

  • What are we prepared to challenge? 

  • What are we prepared to relinquish? 

  • What are we prepared to share? 

  • Who are we prepared to listen to?


Suggested reading:

  • Black and minority ethnic people in Edinburgh face unacceptably high rates of poverty. Poverty rates among Black and Asian people are more than double that of the white British population – 50% of mixed, [B]lack or [B]lack British people, and 43% of Asian or Asian British people in Scotland live in relative poverty – while rates of severe or deep poverty are almost three times as high as the white British population. (pg. 15 - Edinburgh-Poverty-Commission-2025-Calls-to-Action.pdf) 

Previous
Previous

Doing and Learning Update #9

Next
Next

Professional Connectors Circle