Doing and Learning Update #9

Read the PDF of this document here

What is Regenerative Futures Fund? 

 

The Regenerative Futures Fund is a new, ten-year, £15m pooled fund for communities in Edinburgh that puts decision-making power into the hands of those who are most often excluded. This fund is designed by and for people in their own communities.  

 

The funding will give grassroots organisations, collectives, and movements the opportunity to think and plan for the long-term, tackling the root causes of poverty, racism, and the environmental crisis. It supports approaches to improve the lives of people living in poverty and experiencing racism and contribute towards a just green transition by enabling equity, power-sharing, and long-term change. 

 

Doing & Learning Report #9 – Covering September and October 2026 

What is the purpose of this update? We are committed to ‘working in the open’ as we develop the Regenerative Futures Fund. In our team updates, we share what we have been doing, learning, and a bit about how we move forward. These updates are shared with our Oversight & Enabling Board and on the Regenerative Futures Fund website. We – Leah Black, Aala Ross, Andy Hyde, Joe Yauch and Maddy Cross – have written this collaboratively, with future versions to be contributed to by the wider ecosystem.  

  

  1. Fund Design — Process, Programme, & Participation

    Fund Design — Process, Programme 

    We have been: 

    • Delivering a three-week onboarding programme for the funded cohort in September, creating space for organisations to get to know one another, develop a shared sense of purpose and begin exploring what it might mean to work collectively across Edinburgh and to evidence the impact of the cohort over time. 

    • Exploring systems change in practice, building on the Three Horizons work undertaken during the funding process. Using mapping and reflective exercises to help organisations connect their immediate work with the systems they are seeking to influence and the longer-term changes they hope to contribute to. 

    • Using a Rivers of Change exercise to explore the barriers organisations encounter, the conditions that might help change to flow, and the bridges that could connect different efforts across the cohort. 

    • Creating space for conversations about how we want to work together, including accountability between organisations, between the cohort and RFF, and between the Fund and its wider group of funders. Beginning to explore transparency, feedback loops and how we create the conditions for people to raise concerns, offer challenge and learn together. 

    • Developing systems and practices to respond to the needs and asks emerging from the cohort, including planning for a Storytelling Lab with Joe, making meaningful connections between cohort organisations and others, and establishing a process through which organisations can request support from RFF to strengthen their capacity, influence or wider work. 

    • Holding our first Learning Space, facilitated by Nasim Forootan, bringing together funders, residents, RFF and the cohort of community organisations around one of our learning inquiry strands: What are we learning about the systems and culture needed for pooled, resident-led, long-term, unrestricted funding, and the processes and relationships required to do this well? We’re grateful to Nasim for creating a playful and creative afternoon at the Festival Theatre, with zine-making, deep listening walks and opportunities for people to connect as humans beyond their organisational roles, rooted in a shared commitment to ending poverty and shifting power. We will hold Learning Spaces twice a year, with the next planned for spring 2027. 

    • Hosting our first Sharing Ceilidh at the Scottish Storytelling Centre, taking inspiration from our friends at Science Ceilidh and creating a no-pressure space for people to share something of themselves, their lives and what they love. It was a beautiful, buoyant evening, with poems read, handmade objects and treasured things shared, and – just as importantly – quiet conversations, smiles and connections exchanged. A chance to step outside our organisational roles, encounter one another as humans first, and celebrate the Residents’ Panel reaching this point in its journey and the cohort beginning a new ten-year chapter together. It lifted our spirits and reminded us of what becomes possible when relationships, curiosity and generosity sit at the heart of the work. 

    • A huge thank you to Stuart Fallon, curator at City Art Centre for hosting guided tours of the Sandra George exhibition at the City Art Centre in September. Also to Craigmillar Now, a community of volunteers making the work of the artist and community activist Sandra George accessible to Edinburgh residents and audiences further afield. We encourage people to support their work and help bring Sandra's extraordinary legacy to wider audiences. 

     

    Through this we have been learning: 

    • Bringing organisations together through a shared fund does not automatically create a shared identity, purpose or agenda. Building relationships takes time and requires us to create the space for organisations to understand one another’s different histories, contexts, ambitions and ways of working, and to explore connections on their own terms. 

    • Systems change looks different for organisations working at different stages and from different starting points. Making space to connect immediate work with the wider systems organisations seek to influence can help build a shared understanding of change, without assuming that everyone will contribute in the same way or towards the same outcomes. 

    • Making barriers, enabling conditions and potential connections visible can help organisations recognise where their experiences overlap and where there may be opportunities to work together. A shared language can support this, but should not flatten the differences between organisations or prescribe a single approach to change. 

    • Accountability needs to be practised, not simply agreed in principle. Trust depends on creating relationships in which people can be honest, raise difficult issues, offer constructive challenge and give feedback – including where there are differences in power, responsibility and expectations. 

    • That the support structures around a cohort need to evolve in response to what organisations identify as useful, rather than being designed in advance on assumptions about what they need. Our role is to listen, make connections and provide routes to support that strengthen organisations’ capacity, influence and wider work. 

    • That learning is not only about gathering evidence or sharing findings. It also depends on creating the right conditions for people with different roles and perspectives to learn alongside one another. Creative, participatory approaches can help people step outside familiar roles, build relationships and explore the culture and relationships needed to make resident-led, long-term funding work well. 

    • That relationships are at the heart of trust-based philanthropy and relational practice. Systems change is long, demanding, often difficult work, and we need to make time to pause, enjoy one another’s company and fill up each other’s cups now and again – literally and figuratively. Time spent together through art, creativity and shared experiences is part of our aspiration to build a more just future. Making room for people to share what they value, listen to one another and connect beyond organisational roles can strengthen our relationships and remind us of what is possible when we keep going together. 

     

    Fund Design — Participation   

    We have been:  

    • Holding a Strategy Day for residents to help to define a future for the group and to introduce the idea of people taking on new roles or, in some cases, eventually stepping away to enable new people to join. 

    • We talked about what we were leaving behind – the elements of the work that we are unlikely to encounter again as a group (such as decision-making) and other elements we would rather leave behind (such as working under pressure or feeling inexperienced) 

    • Residents shaped a statement about WHY the group should exist in the future: 

    • This is important to us because wealth is not currently evenly distributed and everyone in Edinburgh deserves a good standard of living. We want to tackle the causes of local inequalities and wealth division by supporting work that ensures nobody in the city is living in poverty. 

    • They identified the range of resources available to them including motivation, a desire for change, an activated group and new connections with other groups, the knowledge and skills of the funded cohort, mutual aid within the group, curiosity and much more.  

    • We have since had individual conversations with each resident to determine how they would like to contribute to the future of the group and RFF's work.  

    • We have been in conversation with friends at the Thistle Foundation to explore collaborative support for residents to develop their ideas for future directions.  

    • Similarly, we have had more conversations with colleagues at Turn2Us about their approach to resident participation and supporting them to develop as individuals. 

    • In the meantime, several residents were involved in several onboarding sessions with the funded cohort. These considered 1) the design of the evaluation framework and tools being co-designed with organisations and 2) the learning space that organisations, funders and residents will take part in on a regular basis in the future.  

    • We have become accustomed to creating collective documents such as the group's poem last year. This year's contribution was a collective 'Dear Edinburgh' letter from the group to be included in RFF's 2026 annual report.  

    • A highlight of the past few months was the sharing Ceilidh held in Edinburgh's Storytelling Centre. Emerging from an idea originally put forward by one of the residents, we enjoyed an evening of tales, artworks and poems presented by some of our residents and people based in the funded organisations. Personal, happy and sad reflections as well as hopeful messages accompanied by objects and memories. It was an evening of connection as fellow humans and local neighbours, irrespective of our 'role' in the work.

     

    Through this we have been learning: 

    • The group has identified that they have many resources, beyond money, that they can use to develop the group and themselves in the future. Our collective work is to determine the roles that people will play.  

    • We have been learning from other organisations in the city about the challenges they face in developing support for individuals to thrive in different ways... it takes time and careful guidance.  

    • Having residents involved in the design of processes that will be used by the cohort continues to be valuable.   

    • The new connections and relationships built through bringing residents and funded organisations together in various ways are a key part of the process for decision makers. Having decided to fund projects, the residents have been delighted to see the initial outcomes of their work and would love more of this! 

    • One opportunity we're hoping to start is a regular social gathering for friends of RFF to connect without an agenda.

  2. Recruitment and Team Development

    We have been: 

    • Wrapping up our work with Margaret Morton, fundraising consultant and lawyer who is helping with fundraising and funder and donor development. Margaret has been a brilliant team member over the last year and a huge champion of Regenerative Futures Fund. 

    • Working with Nasim Forootan, who beautifully facilitated our first Learning Space in September 2026, and is helping us think through and strategy for the next phase of our Field Building work. 

    • Spending some 'spacious' time together in North Berwick, for our team strategy day, which was planned and facilitated wonderfully by our EFI colleague and Co-Director of the Scottish Policy and Research Exchange, Catherine-Rose Stocks-Rankin. 

    Through this we have been learning: 

    • An important reminder about the importance of coming together as a team of five and being able to do this in a different location, with a facilitator, gives us the chance to see our work from a different perspective. 

  3. Communications and Open Working

    We have been: 

    • Preparing to publish our second Annual Report in November! This document will summarise the work that we have done between September 2025 and 2026, and it will indicate the direction we are heading in for the next year. In this report, you can expect to find descriptions of how the pooled fund has grown, our cohort onboarding events, the residents’ panel’s stewardship of the grantmaking process, and much more. 

    • Continuing our general communications strategy across our website, LinkedIn, Instagram, and email-- with an eye toward publishing more reflective and analytical pieces going forward. 

    • We also continue to publish our newsletter, What’s Growing, every six weeks, sharing more frequent updates about what we’re doing, reading, and writing. If you would like to be added to the mailing list, please click this link and fill out the form, or email Joe (joseph@foundationscotland.org.uk).  

    • Planning to deliver a series of “storytelling labs” for our funded cohort. Based on a survey of what types of support the cohort would like in their communications work, we are developing a programme to provide training and create collaborative opportunities for the organisations we’re funding. We plan to work with other community organisations that are experts in this arena, and we look forward to learning from the cohort’s skills and experience. 

     

    Through this we have been learning: 

    • That our communications need to serve several purposes at once, and that each piece should take a different form in order to meet those needs. Our work in the third sector tends to push us toward a particular form of writing: long documents, plentiful statistics, industry jargon, acronyms, and analytical terms. That type of writing is useful, but we need to communicate in a variety of formats, styles, and media in order to engage every corner of our community. We’re looking forward to delving deeper into what it means to communicate and tell stories in our upcoming storytelling lab with our funded cohort.

  4. Governance Ecosystem 

    We have been:    

    • Meeting with our Oversight & Enabling Board – Meeting #1 happened in December 2024, Meeting #2 in March 2025, Meeting #3 in June 2025, Meeting #4 in September 2025, Meeting #5 was in December 2025, Meeting #6 was in-person in February 2026, Meeting #7 was in May 2026, Meeting #8 was in August 2026, and Meeting #9 was in November 2026. The next meeting will be in January 2027. 

    • Continuing to think about how to include and engage residents in the wider governance ecosystem, including the Oversight & Enabling Board.  

     

    Through this we have been learning:  

    • That a governance ecosystem is (and should be) an evolving structure that meets the needs of the programme at different stages. As a team, we are grateful to our Oversight & Enabling Board and our Residents Panel for their time, patience and wisdom. 

  5. Fundraising and Contracting

    We have been: 

    • Celebrating that we are sitting at £9.4 million committed to the £15.8 million pooled fund! This total now includes four local philanthropists who give through their own trusts, in addition to larger UK and Scotland-wide focused Foundations and the Local Authority (City of Edinburgh Council). 

    • Building on the first Professional Connectors Circle lunch #1, a new group of professional advisors who we brought together over lunch to share our learning about the ambitions of Regenerative Futures Fund, our newly announced cohort, residents' decision making, and more, learning which they can then pass to clients if the conversation arises. We had our second gathering in September 2026 at Hampden Bank where we did a deeper dive into the themes in the cohort. We are now looking forward to lunch #3 hosted by Turcan Connell in January 2027.  

    • Continually thankful to the funders and donors who have been open to coffees, conversations, introductions, online meetings, and who continue to challenge us on many aspects of the Regenerative Futures Fund.  

    • Deeply appreciative of each introduction or new connection between our existing network and new funders and donors. 

    • Working with a range of UK-wide Trusts and Foundations to develop proposals towards joining the pooled fund. 

    • Continuing our internal work with our colleagues within Foundation Scotland – especially the philanthropy, communications, people and development teams. Thanks to everyone who is helping us in so many ways, this really is a huge collective effort.  

      

    Through this we have been learning: 

    • This type of fundraising – long-term, collaborative, bold, strategic – must be rooted in relationship-building and trust, which means it takes time. 

    • There has been national and international interest in the model from funders, community foundations, local authorities, and community organisations. 

    • There is particular interest in the collaboration with the local authority, as it is seen as a bold move for a local authority to collaborate with funders and charities in this way. 

     

  6. Monitoring, Evaluation, Accountability, and Learning (MEAL)

    We have been: 

    • Co-designing a MEAL framework and set of tools with our funded cohort. During the September onboarding, we held a series of workshops and conversations to better understand: where organisations are now in relation to different M&E tools and their comfort with them; how they currently experience and perceive M&E; and what support from RFF might make the use of particular tools and practices regenerative (rather than extractive) for individual projects and the cohort as a whole. We are also thinking about how RFF can share the work involved in developing and maintaining these processes, including supporting regular data collection and analysis, rather than creating additional demands on organisations already focused on their community work.

    Through this we have been learning: 

    • That MEAL needs to be designed with the cohort, rather than simply designed for them. We are interested not only in what information we need to understand how the Fund is progressing, but in what will be useful to organisations and their communities in understanding, reflecting on and adapting their own work. 

    • That there is a tension between the value of good monitoring and evaluation and the risk of creating additional work that takes people away from their communities. We want to be honest about this tension and explore what RFF can do to carry more of the work, while still building approaches that are meaningful and useful to projects themselves. 

    • That our role as a funder is not simply to collect evidence of impact. We also have a responsibility to create the conditions for learning: making space to notice what is changing, what is not working, what is surprising, and what we might need to do differently. This feels particularly important for a ten-year fund working towards systems change, where much of what matters will not be captured through conventional measures of short-term impact. 

    • That we are still learning what a good MEAL system for a fund like RFF looks and feels like. We expect the approach to evolve with the cohort, rather than being something we finalise at the beginning and then ask everyone to follow. 

  7. Field Building & Systems – Learning with Others, Learning Partnerships, Sharing the Model 

 We have been: 

  • Thinking critically about the “field” that RFF occupies—in other words, we are trying to develop an actionable understanding of which actors, activities, relationships, conditions, power, and opportunities are involved in the same type of systems change work that we are. This exercise is not designed to put ourselves at the centre of the systems change work in Edinburgh. Instead, by taking time to think about the boundaries of this field, why those boundaries exist, who we want to bring into the field, and where the gaps are, we are hoping to identify ways for us to support, amplify, and enable other actors who are already doing important work. We are grateful to Nasim Forootan for facilitating these sessions! 

  • While we continue to develop our field-building resources, here are a few highlights: 

  • Meeting with some of the hard-working people at EVOC, with the goal of connecting our cohort with their services and developing a better understanding of how our two organisations can support one another. 

  • Learning from the amazing team at ESEN about how they support third sector organisations, as well as the thinking behind their robust communications strategy. 

  • In May we launched the report concluding our research project looking into pooled funds for systemic change with community voice at their hearts, which is being generously led by Ben Cairns and Chris Mills from IVAR. The research project includes three Scotland-based pooled funds: Clackmannanshire Transformation Space, the Scottish Human Rights Fund (led by Corra Foundation), and our fund in Edinburgh. The report was launched with an online webinar in May 2026, and there was an in-person launch and panel discussion in Edinburgh on 9 September 2026. 

  • Andy has continued to invite us and our EFI coworking-colleagues to meet and share ideas over an early coffee. We have common interests but rarely get (make) the time to connect intentionally. We are Islands of Coherence that can benefit from connecting, away from the ‘sea of chaos’. Some topics we have covered are field building, the wellbeing economy, the practice of participation, and the role of design in our work. 

  • Leah & Aala are looking forward to delivering a session at the UKCF annual conference with colleagues from City Bridge Foundation, the conference is happening over 24 and 25 November in Nottingham. Read the programme here. Our session will be focused around 'Seeding the future: regenerative funding in practice' 

  • Aala continues to be involved in the Third Sector Poverty Prevention steering group, working with other third sector leaders in Edinburgh to contribute to the co-design of a “£2.5m programme to support third sector delivered activity to prevent and mitigate poverty in Edinburgh.” This work will continue for the next six months, and involve workshops, fora, and facilitated conversations with residents, organisations, and public bodies in the city.  

Through this we have been learning:   

  • From our team away day with Catherine-Rose and from our early exploratory work with Nasim, about the importance of defining the (likely porous) boundary of the ecosystem, or field, in which we work. 

  

If anything chimes with you and you’d like to know more, please do get in touch:   

  

 

Sign up to the Regenerative Futures Fund mailing list here. 

Next
Next

Racial equity cannot wait: a call for collective action in Edinburgh and Scotland